Learn › How to Price a Stock › Module 8

Module 8 · Asset-Based & Special Situations Advanced

Sometimes the value isn't in the future cash flows — it's sitting on the balance sheet right now. This module covers the tools value investors reach for when assets, not growth, tell the story.

~9 min read · Not started

By the end of this module you'll be able to

  • Use book value and tangible book value appropriately.
  • Compute the Graham Number and Earnings Power Value.
  • Recognise net-nets and sum-of-the-parts situations.
  • Know when asset methods beat a DCF.

Book value and tangible book value

Book value per share is accounting net worth per share (Module 2). Tangible book value strips out goodwill and intangibles — the softest assets — leaving the hard stuff. For most modern companies book value badly understates worth, because their real value (brands, code, people) never hits the balance sheet. But for banks and insurers, whose assets are financial, price-to-tangible-book is a core valuation tool (more in Module 9).

Graham's net-net (NCAV)

Benjamin Graham's deepest bargain was the net-net: a stock trading below its net current asset value — current assets minus all liabilities. Buy one and you're effectively getting the entire operating business for free, or better. In the 1930s these littered the market. Today they're vanishingly rare, and finding one usually means something is wrong — a cash-burning business, litigation, or worse. Treat a net-net as a prompt to investigate, not a guaranteed win.

The Graham Number

Graham's compact screen for a defensive stock's maximum reasonable price:

Graham Number = √(22.5 × diluted EPS × book value per share)

The 22.5 is no accident: it's 15 (Graham's maximum sensible P/E) × 1.5 (his maximum sensible P/B). Take a boring industrial with EPS of $4.20 and book value per share of $31.00: √(22.5 × 4.20 × 31.00) = √2,929.5 = $54.12. If the stock trades well below $54, it clears Graham's conservative bar; well above, it doesn't.

What it's good for — and notThe Graham Number is a conservative floor and a screen for profitable, asset-backed value stocks. It is useless for a growth company, whose worth lives in future cash flows the balance sheet can't see. It also requires positive EPS and book value — the square root demands it, so skip the model entirely when either is negative.
Graham Number as a geometric mean A rectangle with sides proportional to 22.5 times EPS and book value; the Graham Number is the side of the square with the same area. Area = 22.5 × EPS × BVPS √area = $54.12 the rectangle
The Graham Number is the geometric mean of earnings power and asset backing — the side of a square with the same area as the “22.5 × EPS × BVPS” rectangle.

Earnings Power Value (Greenwald)

Bruce Greenwald's Earnings Power Value values a business on its current, sustainable earnings with zero growth assumed — a deliberately conservative anchor that avoids the growth guesswork of a DCF:

EPV enterprise value = normalised EBIT × (1 − tax) ÷ WACC

Take normalised EBIT of $1,200M, a 25% tax rate and an 8.35% WACC: after-tax EBIT = $900M; EPV enterprise value = 900 ÷ 0.0835 ≈ $10,778M. Subtract net debt and divide by shares for a per-share figure. Compare EPV to the DCF: if the DCF is far above EPV, you're paying for growth — make sure you believe in it.

Sum-of-the-parts and holding-company discounts

For a conglomerate, one blended multiple hides more than it reveals. Sum-of-the-parts values each division on its own appropriate multiple and adds them up. The total often exceeds the market cap — a holding-company discount — which is common among several TSX holding companies and can be an opportunity if the discount is unusually wide.

Liquidation value and equity as an option

At the extreme, liquidation value asks what the assets would fetch if sold and the debts repaid. In distressed situations, equity behaves like an option on the assets: it pays off only if asset values recover above the debt, and is worth little if they don't. You won't build these often — but recognising when a stock is really a distressed option keeps you from mistaking a lottery ticket for a bargain.

Which method fits which company A grid mapping company types to their best-fit valuation method. Steady cash generator → DCF Dividend payer → DDM Bank / insurer → P/TBV Asset-heavy value → Graham / EPV Conglomerate → sum-of-the-parts Distressed → liquidation / option Pick your method from this map before you touch a single number.
Match the method to the company. The map tells you which models to run — and, just as importantly, which to leave alone.
💡 Hunting for undervalued, asset-backed names? Our Quorum value finder scores fundamentals across 150+ stocks.
← PreviousDCF Part II

Educational purposes only; not financial advice. Example figures are illustrative. Always do your own research and consult a licensed advisor.